Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"
Become a host
Gay Travel Resources
Icon symbolizing "Sign Up"
Sign up
Icon symbolizing "Log In"
Log in
Explore Gay Accommodations in Sayville
Check-in
-
Checkout
1 guest, 1 bedroom
Search
Type of space
Entire Place
Hotel
Freshly Updated!
Price
clothing optional
Filters
Map
Please
select dates
to see availability and prices
See Ranking criteria
Vincent
Private room • 11.1 miles from Sayville
★
4.93 (14)
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Clothing optional accepted • Host shares gay local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
See prices
Robert
Private room • 4.4 miles from Sayville
★
5 (4)
Rooms near beach and train to NYC
Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning
See prices
Alan
Entire place • 4.8 miles from Sayville
★
5 (3)
The poolhouse at Shady Walk
Gay District • Hot tub • Pets allowed
See prices
Mark
Private room • Sayville
★
5 (1)
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Breakfast included • Air conditioning • Heating
See prices
William
Entire place • 4.9 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Stay at Daddy’s House!!
Gay District • Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning
See prices
Skie
Private room • 4.9 miles from Sayville
★
New
2025 Summer Rentals, Fire Island Pines
Gay District • Host shares gay local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
See prices
Vijay
Private room • 5.2 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room
Gay District • Breakfast included • Hot tub
See prices
Jon
Entire place • 5 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views
Gay District • Air conditioning • Kitchen
See prices
Robert
Private room • 4.4 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal
Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning
See prices
Giovanni
Private room • 8.2 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********
Clothing optional accepted • Breakfast included • Parking
See prices
Michael
Private room • 4.9 miles from Sayville
★
5 (1)
Room 5 in superbly-located house on Fire Island Pines.
Gay District • Host shares gay local tips • Air conditioning
See prices
Joe
Approval
Instant
Entire place • 4.9 miles from Sayville
Luxury Pines 5BR Gourmet Kit, Pool, Jacuzzi, A/C, 360˚ Views, Private
Gay District • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby
See prices
Mark
★ 5 as host
Private room • Sayville
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Mae West Room
Breakfast included • Air conditioning • Heating
See prices
Page 1
>
Trustpilot