Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"
Become a host
Gay Travel Resources
Icon symbolizing "Sign Up"
Sign up
Icon symbolizing "Log In"
Log in
Explore Gay Accommodations in Fire Island Pines
Check-in
-
Checkout
1 guest, 1 bedroom
Search
Type of space
Entire Place
Hotel
gay district
Freshly Updated!
Price
clothing optional
Filters
Map
Please
select dates
to see availability and prices
See Ranking criteria
Vincent
Private room • 11.9 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.93 (14)
Clothing Optional: Private room/bath, near beach & Fire Island Ferry
Clothing optional accepted • Host shares gay local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
See prices
Robert
Private room • 8 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
5 (4)
Rooms near beach and train to NYC
Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning
See prices
Alan
Entire place • Fire Island Pines
★
5 (3)
The poolhouse at Shady Walk
Gay District • Hot tub • Pets allowed
See prices
Mark
Private room • 5.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Breakfast included • Air conditioning • Heating
See prices
William
Entire place • Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Stay at Daddy’s House!!
Gay District • Dedicated workspace • Air conditioning
See prices
Vijay
Private room • 1.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Samsara-Nirvana-The Yacht Room
Gay District • Breakfast included • Hot tub
See prices
Jon
Entire place • Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Fire Island Pines 2bed/2.5bath +cabana, heated pool, great ocean views
Gay District • Air conditioning • Kitchen
See prices
Robert
Private room • 8 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Rooms near Village of Patchogue & train to NYC, beach ferries seasonal
Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning
See prices
Giovanni
Private room • 10 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Slice of heaven - Superhost on ********
Clothing optional accepted • Breakfast included • Parking
See prices
Michael
Private room • Fire Island Pines
★
5 (1)
Room 5 in superbly-located house on Fire Island Pines.
Gay District • Host shares gay local tips • Air conditioning
See prices
Joe
Approval
Instant
Entire place • Fire Island Pines
Luxury Pines 5BR Gourmet Kit, Pool, Jacuzzi, A/C, 360˚ Views, Private
Gay District • LGBTQ+ venues nearby • Gym nearby
See prices
Skie
Private room • 0.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
New
2025 Summer Rentals, Fire Island Pines
Gay District • Host shares gay local tips • LGBTQ+ venues nearby
See prices
Mark
★ 5 as host
Private room • 5.1 miles from Fire Island Pines
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Mae West Room
Breakfast included • Air conditioning • Heating
See prices
Page 1
>
Trustpilot