Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"
Become a host
Gay Travel Resources
Icon symbolizing "Sign Up"
Sign up
Icon symbolizing "Log In"
Log in
Gay and Gay-friendly Hotels in Shelter Island
Check-in
-
Checkout
1 guest, 1 bedroom
Search
Hotel room
Entire Place
most booked
LGBTQ+ friendly
Price
best rated
Filters
Map
Please
select dates
to see availability and prices
See Ranking criteria
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 2.6 miles from Shelter Island
★
5 (1)
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Private beach
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room * • 4.2 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.72 (1)
Southold Beach Motel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • Shelter Island
★
4.64 (1)
Rams Head Inn
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Private beach
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 5.1 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.8 (1)
Sag Harbor Inn
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 2.6 miles from Shelter Island
★
5 (1)
The Menhaden Hotel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Pets allowed
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 3.4 miles from Shelter Island
★
5 (1)
The Shoals Suites & Slips
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 5.1 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.8 (1)
Baron's Cove
🏆 Pride Points x3
Breakfast included • Wi-Fi • Pool
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 3.5 miles from Shelter Island
★
5 (1)
Hotel Moraine
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
See prices
Best rated LGBTQ+ hosts by our community in Shelter Island
#1
J Mickey
Private room • East Hampton
★
5 (2)
Acorn Room at Ober Oaks
Air conditioning • Heating • Dryer
See prices
#2
John
Private room • Southold
★
5 (1)
THE BOSSY DOXIE INN: Southold's Newest and Chicest B&B--Room 4
Breakfast included • Dedicated workspace • Hot tub
See prices
#3
Carl and David
Private room • Hampton Bays
★
5 (1)
Hamptons Beach House with Pool
Parking • Air conditioning • Kitchen
See prices
SHOW 20 MORE »
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 2.6 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.76 (1)
The Harbor Front Inn
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 2.7 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.88 (1)
American Beech Hotel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pets allowed • Restaurant
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 5 miles from Shelter Island
★
4.64 (1)
Historic White Blossom House
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Pets allowed
See prices
Friendly
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • Shelter Island
★
5 (1)
The Pridwin Hotel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Spa
See prices
Page 1
>
Trustpilot