Leader in Gay Travel for Ten Years
Icon symbolizing the community
Community
icon symbolizing "Become a host"
Become a host
Gay Travel Resources
Icon symbolizing "Sign Up"
Sign up
Icon symbolizing "Log In"
Log in
Gay and Gay-friendly Hotels in Fire Island Pines
Check-in
-
Checkout
1 guest, 1 bedroom
Search
Hotel room
Entire Place
most booked
LGBTQ+ friendly
gay district
Price
best rated
Filters
Map
Please
select dates
to see availability and prices
See Ranking criteria
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 4.8 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.64 (1)
Clegg's Hotel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Gay District • Wi-Fi • Bar
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room • 3.9 miles from Fire Island Pines
Coastal Cove Cottage
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room * • 14 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
2 (1)
Relax Inn North Babylon
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 10.4 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.84 (1)
112 Motel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Hot tub • Parking
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 16.8 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
3.64 (1)
South Bay Motel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Hot tub • Parking
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room **** • 18.3 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.08 (1)
Hollywood Motel
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Adult Only • Hot tub
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 8.6 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
3.56 (1)
The Starwood Inn
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 9.3 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.08 (1)
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking
See prices
Best rated LGBTQ+ hosts by our community in Fire Island Pines
#1
Robert
Private room • Patchogue
★
5 (4)
Rooms near beach and train to NYC
Hot tub • Parking • Air conditioning
See prices
#2
Alan
Entire place • Fire Island Pines
★
5 (3)
The poolhouse at Shady Walk
Gay District • Hot tub • Pets allowed
See prices
#3
Mark
Private room • Sayville
★
5 (1)
C1870’s period Colonial Home nearby Fire Island. The Tammy Room
Breakfast included • Air conditioning • Heating
See prices
SHOW 26 MORE »
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 17.5 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
3.52 (1)
Americas Best Value Inn - Port Jefferson Station - Long Island
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Smoking allowed
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room ** • 18 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.36 (1)
Three Village Inn
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Parking • Beachfront
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 9.5 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.88 (1)
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
See prices
Welcoming
Approval
Instant
Hotel room *** • 10.2 miles from Fire Island Pines
★
4.84 (1)
Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma
🏆 Pride Points x3
Wi-Fi • Pool • Parking
See prices
Page 1
>
Trustpilot